Agriculture

Galway farmer found guilty over threats to neighbour in missing dog dispute

Brian Gill was found guilty of threatening and abusive words against Brian Murphy in two incidents, but Judge Adrian Harris applied the Probation Act for a year.

Tuva NybergOctober 19, 20265 min read7 views

A narrow country lane at dusk between two neighbouring farmyards, with an empty dog lead hanging from a wooden gate post.

A Co. Galway farmer has been found guilty of using threatening, abusive and insulting words towards a neighbouring farmer, in a case rooted in a long-running dispute that flared over a missing dog.

At Gort District Court, Judge Adrian Harris found Brian Gill (44), of Cahermore, Kinvara, guilty of engaging in threatening, abusive and insulting words against Brian Murphy with intent to provoke a breach of the peace in two separate incidents, on May 21, 2025 and February 2 of this year.

The judge did not convict Gill of either offence and instead applied the Probation Act for one year. He told Gill that if the Probation Service recommends he complete an anger management course, he must do so. Judge Harris said there was a context to the offences and clearly ill feeling between the two men going back some time, and said Gill should not engage in behaviour amounting to these offences.

The missing dog

Gill told the court his dog went missing on May 19, 2025, and that he received a phone call on July 1 saying the dog was 35km away. "That dog did not walk 35 kilometres," he said.

Giving evidence about the May 21, 2025 incident at Caherawoneen South, Kinvara, Brian Murphy said Gill accused him of stealing the dog and said "I will get you" when the two met while driving on a narrow road at around 9pm. Murphy said he knew nothing about the dog and did not say a word to Gill.

Martin Durack, counsel for Gill, said there was an agrarian background to the incident and that there had been disputes in the past regarding fences and similar matters. Under cross-examination, he put it to Murphy that there was animosity between the men and that they were not "on each other's Christmas card list". Murphy replied: "Every time I am on the road he causes trouble."

Denial of threat

In evidence, Gill denied threatening Murphy. He said he only asked him where his dog was and that Murphy called him a fool, to which he replied that Murphy was "the only fool who sells top soil from his farm".

Gill said three people had told him the dog was spotted in the back of Murphy's yard, but he declined to identify any of them. He said Murphy "had a sarcastic smile on his face as he usually does and that raised my suspicions". He added: "He knew something about the dog — I don't think he had the dog because the dog wouldn't have gone to him."

Gill described the dog as "a one person dog" and said there was "a sentimental attachment" and "a bit of history" between them. Cross-examined by Insp. Daragh Browne, he said he was angry because the matter had been going on for the past 10 years, and told the judge: "This is the 15th time I have been in court over this fella — directly or indirectly."

Insp. Browne said Gill remained "very frustrated" and still believed someone had removed the dog. Durack said that while Gill's language may have been brusque, there was no threat and no intention to cause a breach of the peace.